A Different Man-Movie Review

By Rob Hinkal

In A Different Man, Sebastian Stan solidifies his standing as one of the most unique actors working today.

Following Edward, a struggling actor with a facial deformity who is given the chance to change his appearance via a new medical drug, Man harkens back to the early works of Charlie Kaufman in its outlandish, and at times whimsical tone. This is one of the better films I have seen this year thanks to the incredible performances of not only Stan but also Adam Pearson (whom some of you may recognize from Jonathan Glazer’s Under the Skin), who brings so much joy and warmth to his scenes and proves to be a magnetic screen presence. Stan, who spends a good deal of the film covered in makeup and totally unrecognizable, delivers arguably his best performance yet showing a full gamut of emotions and vulnerability.

Another review for the film I encountered mentioned that the plot does stray a bit too far from reality by the end, and I agree. Can’t say I hate the ending as it does create a nice, complete narrative structure, but the criticism is still valid. There are some questionable occurrences throughout, mainly in the second half that are far-fetched and contrast with the more personal, human story that is presented throughout the first part of the film. That’s not to say the quality of the film is lessened as plot holes become apparent, but it is certainly noticeable that things take some outlandish turns.  

For me, it was difficult to discern what the true meaning of the story was. It plays with many universal concepts, but I did feel confused regarding what the audience was supposed to gather from this man’s experience. The story is acted out with sublime performances and the themes are well represented, but I am just not sure what the true idea of the film is. Perhaps something to do with identity and what we attribute to the identity of others? 

Grievances aside, this is a truly unique and fascinating film bolstered by incredible performances, sharp filmmaking, and thought-provoking ideas. I highly recommend it.

4 stars out of 5