‘Heretic’ Movie Review

By Rob Hinkal

Hugh Grant fully encapsulates how I feel when discussing my interests on a date in Heretic.

Heretic is not like much else you will see this year. Not only does it deliver the suspense, and a few of the scares that A24 has come to be recognized for, but nearly the entire film revolves around one central idea: belief. 

You won’t see many mainstream releases that dedicate a good third of their runtime to a philosophical debate regarding the origins and ideas presented in organized religion, but Heretic plows through full steam ahead. Arguably the best portion of the film is the first 45 minutes or so which is almost exclusively dialogue-driven. The performances and dedication of the three members of the central cast are extraordinary. Hugh Grant, in particular, is a total blast to watch and easily maneuvers between his charming “Four Weddings and a Funeral” persona, and something much darker than we have ever seen from the veteran actor before. Sophia Thatcher and Chloe East also excel in the film as the Mormon missionaries, with each one of them bringing a true sense of vulnerability and strength to their respective roles.

What comes after the dialogue-heavy first third of the film is strictly spoiler territory, but what I can say is that while it still delivers plenty of surprises, it just doesn’t have the same spark. In essence, it turns more into a thriller than a horror film. A game of cat and mouse between a heady psychopath and two women being forced to reckon with deep questions they have never had to face. And when the conclusion is reached, it does feel like a point is being made that could have been communicated much more simply and quickly. 

Come to Heretic for the thrills, and stay for the fantastic performances and intriguing philosophical arguments it offers. Hugh Grant should only be allowed to play villains from now on. 

3.5 out of 5 stars